Elastic HA for Avi Service Engines

High Availability Modes

Avi Vantage supports two Avi Service Engine (SE) elastic HA modes which combine scale-out performance as well as high availability: N+M mode (the default) and active/active. Avi Vantage also provides a third mode, legacy HA mode, which enables a smooth migration from legacy appliance-based load balancers.

Elastic HA N+M Mode

N+M is the default mode for elastic HA.

  • In this mode, each virtual service is typically placed on just one SE.
  • The “N” in “N+M” is the minimum number of SEs required to place virtual services in the SE group — this calculation is done by the Avi Controller based on the “Virtual Services per Service Engine” parameter (labeled A in the figures). N will vary over time, as virtual services are placed on or removed from the group. Maximum number of Service Engines is labeled E.
  • The “M”of “N+M” is the number of additional SEs the Avi Controller spins up to handle up to M SE failures without reducing the capacity of the SE group. M appears in the “Buffer Service Engines” field (labeled D in the figures).
  • The minimum scale per virtual service is labeled B and maximum scale per virtual service is labeled C.
Figure 1a. SE editor Basic Settings tab with elastic HA N+M mode selected and two parameters set.
Figure 1b. SE editor Advanced tab, Advanced HA & Placement section, with three parameters set.

Elastic HA N+M Example

The left side of figure 2 shows 20 virtual service placements on an SE group. With Virtual Services per SE set to 8, N is 3 (20/8 = 2.5, which rounds to 3). With M = 1, a total of N+M = 3 + 1 = 4 SEs are required in the group. 2

Note that no single SE in the group is completely idle. Avi Controller places virtual services on all available SEs. In N+M mode, Avi Vantage ensures enough buffer capacity exists in aggregate to handle one (M=1) SE failure. In this example, each of the 4 SEs has 5 virtual services placed. A total of 12 spare slots are still available for additional VS placements, which is sufficient to handle one SE failure.

The right side of figure 2 shows the SE group just after SE2 has failed. The 5 virtual services in SE2 have been placed onto spare slots found on surviving SEs: SE1, SE3, and S4.

Figure 2. Elastic HA N+M group with 20 virtual services, before and after a failure. Virtual Services per Service Engine = 8, N = 3, M = 1, compact placement = ON.
Figure 3. Avi Vantage spins up a replacement SE to once again satisfy the M=1 condition.

As shown in figure 3, with only 4 slots remaining just after the 5 re-placements, if Avi Vantage’s orchestrator mode is set to write access, Avi Vantage spins up SE5 to meet the M=1 condition, which in this case requires at least 8 slots available for re-placements.

The imbalance in loading disappears over time if one or both of two things happens:

  1. New virtual services are placed on the group. As many as 4 virtual services could be placed without compromising the M=1 condition. They would be placed on SE5 because Avi Vantage chooses the least-loaded SE first.
  2. The Auto-Rebalance option is selected (depicted in figure 8).

With M set to 1, the SE group is single-SE fault tolerant. Customers desiring multiple-SE fault tolerance set M higher. Avi Vantage permits M to be dynamically increased by the administrator without interrupting any services. Consequently, one may start with M=1 (typical of most N+M deployments), and increase it if conditions warrant.

If an N+M group has scaled out to Max Number of Service Engines and N x Virtual Services per SE have been placed, Avi Vantage will permit additional VS placements (into the spare capacity represented by M), but an HA_COMPROMISED event will be logged.

Elastic HA Active/Active

In active/active mode, Avi Vantage places each virtual service on more than one Avi SE, as specified by “Minimum Scale per Virtual Service” parameter (labeled B in the figures) — the default minimum is 2. If an SE in the group fails, then

  • Virtual services that had been running are not interrupted. They continue to run on other SEs with degraded capacity until they can be placed once again.
  • If Avi Vantage’s orchestrator mode is set to write access, a new SE is automatically deployed to bring the SE group back to its previous capacity. After waiting for the new SE to spin up, the Avi Controller places on it the virtual services that had been running on the failed SE.
Figure 4a. SE editor Basic Settings tab with elastic HA active-active mode selected and two parameters set.
Figure 4b. SE editor Advanced tab, Advanced HA & Placement section, with three parameters set.

Elastic HA Active/Active Example

Figures 5 through 7 illustrate an SE failure and full recovery. Figure 5 shows an SE group in which

  • Virtual Services per Service Engine = 3 (label A in the UI)
  • Minimum Scale per Virtual Service = 2 (label B)
  • Maximum Scale per Virtual Service = 4 (label C)
  • Max Number of Services Engines = 6 (label E)

Over time, five virtual services (VS1-VS5) have been placed. One of them, VS3, has been scaled from its initial two placements to three, illustrating Avi Vantage’s support for “N-way active” virtual services.

Figure 5. Five virtual services placed on an active/active SE group.

SE3 fails, as depicted in figure 6. As a result, one of two VS2 instances fails and one of three VS3 instances fails. Three other virtual services (VS1, VS4, VS5) are unaffected. Neither VS2 nor VS3 are interrupted because of instances previously placed on SE4, SE5, and SE6. They continue, albeit with degraded performance.

Figure 6. A single SE fails in an active/active SE group.

As shown in figure 7, the Avi Controller deploys SE7 as a replacement for SE3, and places VS2 and VS3 on it, bringing both virtual services up to their prior level of performance.

Figure 7. Recovery of a single SE in an active/active SE group

Virtual Service Placement Policy

This section explains the interaction between the elastic HA modes and Avi Vantage’s VS placement policy for the SE group.

Figure 8a. Virtual Service Placement Policy section of SE Group Basic Settings showing default auto-rebalancing settings.
Figure 8b. Virtual Service Placement Policy section of SE Group Basic Settings showing default auto-rebalancing settings.

Compact Placement

When compact placement is ON (label G in figure 8b), Avi Vantage uses the minimum number of SEs required. When distributed placement is ON, Avi Vantage will use as many SEs as required, up to the limit allowed by Max Number of Service Engines (labeled E in the figures). By default, compact placement is ON for elastic HA N+M mode while distributed placement is ON for elastic HA active/active mode.

Compact Placement Example

Figure 9 shows the effect of compact placement on an elastic HA N+M SE group where the Max Number of Service Engines is 4.

In both the compact and distributed placement examples:

  • Eight virtual services are created in sequence.
  • After VS1 is placed, SE2 is deployed because M=1 (handle one SE failure).
  • When VS2 requires placement, Avi Vantage assigns it to otherwise idle SE2 to make best use of all running SEs.

At this point, placement behavior diverges.

Compact Placement ON. Subsequent placements of VS3 through VS8 require no additional SEs to maintain HA (M=1 => one SE failure). With compact placement ON, Avi Vantage prefers to place virtual services on existing SEs.

Distributed Placement ON. Subsequent placements of VS3 and VS4 result in scaling the SE group out to its maximum, 4, illustrating Avi Vantage’s preference for performance at the expense of resources. Having reached 4 deployed SEs, the maximum number of SEs for this group, Avi Vantage places virtual services VS5 through VS8 on pre-existing, least-loaded SEs.

compact placement on and off Figure 9. Elastic HA N+1 SE group with compact placement ON and OFF. Eight successive VS placements shown.

Interaction of Compact Placement with Elastic HA Modes

Compact placement interacts in a subtle way with the elastic HA modes in regards to timing.

Elastic HA N+M mode. In figure 2, because compact placement is ON by default in N+M mode, the Avi Controller deferred deployment of spare capacity, preferring instead to immediately pack virtual services densely onto existing SEs.

Elastic HA active/active mode. In figure 7, because distributed placement option is ON by default in active/active mode, the Avi Controller delays the placement of VS2 and VS3 until replacement SE7 spin ups. No additional burden is placed on the four surviving SEs (SE1, SE2, SE4, SE5). Instead, both virtual services are placed on a fresh SE, so that all virtual services may perform as they did before the failure.

Auto-Rebalance

The Auto-Rebalance option (label F in figure 8a) applies only to the elastic HA modes, and is OFF by default . If selected, virtual services will be automatically migrated or scaled out / scaled in when the load on the SEs goes above the maximum threshold or falls below the minimum threshold. Figure 3 shows a use case.

As shown in figure 8a, the rebalancing interval may be chosen with a resolution of one second.

If auto-rebalance is left in its default OFF state, an event is logged instead of automatically performing migrations.

Configuring Elastic HA

To configure elastic HA for an SE group:

  1. Navigate to Infrastructure > Clouds.
  2. Click on the cloud name (for example, "Default-Cloud").
  3. Click Service Engine Group.
  4. Click the edit icon next to the SE group name, or click Create to create new one.
  5. Fill out the requisite fields.
  6. Click Save.

Notes and Recommendations

Elastic HA N + M mode (the default) is typically applied to applications wherein the following conditions apply:

  1. The SE performance required by any application can be delivered by a fraction of one SE's capacity, hence each VS is typically placed on a single SE.
  2. Applications can tolerate brief outages, albeit no longer than it takes to place a VS on an existing SE and plumb its network connections. This is usually no more than a few seconds.

The pre-existence of buffer SE capacity, coupled with the default setting of compact placement ON, speeds re-placement of virtual services affected by a failure. Avi Vantage doesn’t wait for a substitute SE to be spun up; it immediately places affected virtual services on spare capacity.

Most applications’ need for HA is satisfied by M=1. However, in dev/test environments, M may be set to 0, since the dev/test users can wait for a new SE to be spun up before the VS is placed again.

Elastic HA active/active mode is typically applied to mission-critical applications where the virtual services must continue without interruption during the recovery period.

Updated: 2017-12-15 14:07:08 +0000